Best Medicare Advantage Plans | Aetna Vs Humana

What are Medicare Advantage Plans

This post may contain affiliate links, meaning I may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I trust. Thank you for your support.

Medicare Advantage plans offer an alternative to Original Medicare, integrating hospital (Part A), medical (Part B), and often prescription drug (Part D) coverage into one plan, along with extra benefits.

These plans are offered by private insurance companies approved by Medicare and provide all of the benefits covered by Original Medicare, along with additional benefits such as prescription drug coverage, dental, vision, and hearing services.

Medicare Advantage Plans work by combining the coverage of Medicare Parts A (hospital insurance) and B (medical insurance) into a single plan. They often include extra benefits like gym memberships and wellness programs.

These plans are an attractive option for many seniors because they offer comprehensive coverage and can help manage healthcare costs.

Why Choose Medicare Advantage?

Medicare Advantage plans are popular because they provide a simplified, streamlined way to receive comprehensive health care.

They are especially beneficial for those who prefer:

• A single plan that integrates multiple aspects of coverage (hospital, medical, and prescription)
• Additional benefits that support overall well-being beyond traditional healthcare, such as dental and vision care, wellness programs, and telehealth services
• Predictable out-of-pocket expenses thanks to annual spending caps

Key Features of Medicare Advantage Plans

1. Bundled Coverage: Medicare Advantage consolidates hospital (Part A), medical (Part B), and usually prescription drug (Part D) coverage into one plan. This all-in-one approach can simplify healthcare management since there is only one plan to administer.
2. Extra Benefits: Many Medicare Advantage plans offer added services that Original Medicare does not cover. These extra benefits may include:

• Dental, vision, and hearing services
• Fitness memberships and wellness programs
• Transportation to medical appointments
• Over-the-counter medication allowances
• Telehealth services

3. Plan Types: There are several types of Medicare Advantage plans, each with its own network and structure:
4. Health Maintenance Organizations (HMOs): Typically require members to use a network of doctors and facilities and often need referrals for specialist care.
5. Preferred Provider Organizations (PPOs): Offer more flexibility when choosing healthcare providers and may cover a portion of out-of-network care, though at higher cost.
6. Special Needs Plans (SNPs): Target individuals with specific chronic conditions or other special healthcare needs.
7. Cost Structure and Predictability: These plans usually have a defined annual out-of-pocket maximum, which means that once you reach this limit, the plan covers 100% of your costs for covered services for the rest of the year.

The Best Medicare Advantage Plans

Several Medicare Advantage Plans stand out as top choices. These plans offer comprehensive coverage, affordable costs, and a wide range of additional benefits.

Some of the best Medicare Advantage Plans include:

1. Aetna Medicare Advantage Premier Plus (HMO): This plan provides comprehensive coverage, including dental, vision, and hearing benefits. It also has a low monthly premium and a network of trusted providers.
2. Humana Gold Plus (HMO): Humana Gold Plus offers a range of additional benefits, including fitness memberships and a 24/7 nurse helpline. It also has a low out-of-pocket maximum for added financial protection.
3. UnitedHealthcare Medicare Advantage (PPO): UnitedHealthcare offers a PPO plan with a wide network of providers and additional benefits like wellness programs and prescription drug coverage. This plan provides flexibility in choosing healthcare providers.
4. Cigna-HealthSpring Advantage (HMO): Cigna’s Advantage plan provides comprehensive coverage, including prescription drug benefits. It emphasizes preventive care and wellness programs to keep seniors healthy.
5. Kaiser Permanente Medicare Advantage (HMO): Known for its integrated healthcare approach, Kaiser Permanente offers a Medicare Advantage plan with a focus on coordinated and efficient care. It often includes coverage for vision and hearing services.
6. Blue Cross Blue Shield Medicare Advantage (PPO): Blue Cross Blue Shield’s PPO plan provides a broad network of healthcare providers, allowing seniors more flexibility in choosing their doctors and specialists. It also typically includes additional benefits like fitness programs.
7. WellCare Medicare Advantage (HMO): WellCare’s HMO plan offers cost-effective coverage with emphasis on preventive care. It often includes added perks like transportation services for medical appointments.
8. Anthem MediBlue Access (PPO): Anthem’s PPO plan provides seniors with a wide network of healthcare providers and the flexibility to see specialists without referrals. It also often includes coverage for prescription drugs.
9. AARP MedicareComplete (HMO): AARP, in collaboration with UnitedHealthcare, offers a comprehensive HMO plan with coverage for prescription drugs and a range of wellness programs. It may also include additional benefits like vision and dental coverage.
10. Medicare Advantage by Devoted Health (HMO): Devoted Health focuses on personalized care and offers an HMO plan with comprehensive coverage. It often includes benefits such as dental, vision, and hearing coverage along with innovative healthcare solutions.

How Medicare Advantage Plans Work

1. Enrollment and Eligibility

• To be eligible for a Medicare Advantage plan, you must be enrolled in Medicare Part A and Part B.
• Enrollment periods typically occur during the Annual Enrollment Period (AEP), but there may be additional opportunities (such as a Special Enrollment Period) under certain circumstances.

2. Provider Networks

• Unlike Original Medicare, which allows you to see any doctor or hospital that accepts Medicare, Medicare Advantage plans often work with defined provider networks.
• This means that choosing a provider within the plan’s network usually leads to lower out-of-pocket costs. Some plan types, like PPOs, offer options for out-of-network care albeit at a higher cost.

3. Plan Changes and Updates

• Insurance companies might alter the benefits, network providers, or cost-sharing structures based on regional healthcare needs and updated Medicare guidelines.
• It’s important to review your plan every year during the enrollment period.

Aetna Medicare vs. Humana Medicare Advantage

1. Plan Options and Flexibility

Aetna Medicare:

• Offers a broad spectrum of plan types including HMOs, PPOs, Special Needs Plans (SNPs), and sometimes additional standalone prescription drug plans (Part D).
• Their offerings are well regarded for providing flexibility in plan design, with options often tailored to regions and local populations.
• Emphasis is placed on supplemental benefits such as dental, vision, hearing, and wellness programs.

Humana Medicare:

• Also provides a variety of plan types, including HMOs and PPOs, with a strong emphasis on integrated care and wellness programs.
• Often noted for innovative care management initiatives, Humana’s plans may include extras like fitness memberships, care coordination services, and extensive telehealth options.
• Plans are designed to support chronic care management, with resources aimed at keeping members healthy and preventing hospitalizations.

2. Provider Networks and Coverage

Aetna Medicare:

• Typically has a large, nationwide network of providers, making it easier for beneficiaries who travel or live in multiple locations.
• Plans are generally structured to offer a balance between cost savings and access to a wide range of specialists and hospitals.
• May offer flexibility with out-of-network coverage depending on the plan type (e.g., PPOs).

Humana Medicare:

• Known for building strong regional provider networks with partnerships that often emphasize quality and cost efficiency.
• Some Humana plans may have more localized networks, so beneficiaries should verify that their preferred providers and hospitals are included in the network.
• Their PPO options, where available, typically provide more freedom to seek out-of-network care while still managing costs through tiered benefit structures.

3. Additional Benefits

Aetna Medicare:

• Beyond basic medical and prescription coverage, many plans include extras such as fitness memberships, transportation benefits, and health management programs (including disease management and preventive care services).
• Also often provide digital tools and member portals for managing benefits, scheduling appointments, and accessing telehealth services.

Humana Medicare:

• Typically emphasizes integrated wellness and preventive care through programs like personalized health coaching, virtual care visits, and comprehensive care management services.
• Often include benefits like over-the-counter allowances, dental and vision coverage, and enhanced digital health tools to track and manage health.
• Many Humana plans promote community-based programs and incentives for staying active and engaged in managing one’s health.

4. Cost Structure and Out-of-Pocket Expenses

Aetna Medicare:

• Premiums, deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance vary widely by region and plan type.
• Plans are structured to competitively manage out-of-pocket costs, and many offer an annual out-of-pocket maximum to protect beneficiaries from high costs.
• Beneficiaries are encouraged to review plan details carefully since cost-sharing structures can vary.

Humana Medicare:

• Often competitive in premium pricing, with many plans designed to reduce cost-sharing burdens.
• Emphasis is placed on predictable cost-sharing models—such as fixed copayments for common services—to help beneficiaries manage their health care expenses.
• As with Aetna, out-of-pocket maximums are a key feature, though the specific terms depend on the plan and geographical region.

5. Customer Service and Technology

Aetna Medicare:

• Generally receives favorable reviews for customer support, with strong online resources, mobile apps, and dedicated member service lines.
• Investments in digital tools and data-driven health management services help members stay informed about their health.

Humana Medicare:

• Frequently recognized for excellent customer service and personalized care management, including proactive outreach for care coordination.
• Their online platform and mobile applications are noted for ease of use, often providing comprehensive resources such as virtual health visits, benefit tracking, and wellness tools.

6. Member Satisfaction and Star Ratings

Aetna Medicare:

• Many plans achieve competitive star ratings from CMS, reflective of member satisfaction, preventive care measures, and effective management of chronic conditions.
• Continuous improvements in customer support and extra-benefits are often highlighted in beneficiary feedback.

Humana Medicare:

• Often earns strong ratings based on quality of care and customer service.
• Their commitment to integrated care and accessible health services is often cited as a key strength, though ratings can vary regionally.

Who Has the Best Medicare Advantage Plans?

Determining who has the best Medicare Advantage Plans in 2024 ultimately depends on your specific healthcare needs and preferences.

Aetna Medicare and Humana Medicare are both reputable insurance providers offering a range of plans with comprehensive coverage and additional benefits.

However, other insurers also offer competitive plans worth considering.

To find the best Medicare Advantage Plans for your needs, it’s essential to compare plans based on factors such as network, prescription drug coverage, additional benefits, and costs. Consider reaching out to insurance brokers or using online resources to help you navigate the various options available and make an informed decision.

Tips for Choosing the Best Medicare Advantage Plan for Your Needs

Choosing the best Medicare Advantage Plans for your needs can be a daunting task, but these tips can help simplify the process:

1. Assess your healthcare needs: Consider the medications you take, the doctors you prefer to see, and any specific health conditions you have. This will help you determine which plan provides the most comprehensive coverage.
2. Review the plan’s network: Ensure that your preferred healthcare providers are included in the plan’s network, or that the plan allows you to see out-of-network providers if necessary.
3. Evaluate prescription drug coverage: If you take regular medications, ensure that the plan provides adequate prescription drug coverage. Review the plan’s formulary to see if your medications are covered and at what cost.
4. Consider additional benefits: Determine if the plan offers any additional benefits that are important to you, such as dental, vision, or hearing services. These extra benefits can contribute to your overall healthcare experience.
5. Compare costs: Review the plan’s costs, including premiums, deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance. Consider your budget and how much you’re willing to pay for healthcare services.
6. Check star ratings: Consider the plan’s star ratings, which provide an indication of the plan’s quality and customer satisfaction. Higher star ratings generally reflect better overall performance.

Understanding Medicare Benefits and Coverage Under Advantage Plans

Medicare Advantage Plans provide comprehensive coverage for Medicare Parts A and B, along with additional benefits not covered by Original Medicare.

These additional benefits may include prescription drug coverage, dental, vision, and hearing services, fitness programs, and more.

It’s essential to understand the specific benefits and coverage offered by your Medicare Advantage Plan.

Review the plan’s Summary of Benefits and Coverage, which provides a detailed overview of what is included.

Pay attention to any limitations or restrictions, such as prior authorization requirements or network restrictions, to ensure you fully understand how the plan works.

Keep in mind that Medicare Advantage Plans must cover all of the services covered by Original Medicare, but they may do so with different cost-sharing arrangements.

Review the plan’s cost-sharing structure, including copayments, coinsurance, and deductibles, to understand your financial responsibilities.

Medicare Advantage Plans in Nursing Homes

Medicare Advantage plans like Aetna Medicare Advantage Premier Plus (HMO), Humana Gold Plus (HMO) and the rest bring an added layer of flexibility to post-hospitalization care, going beyond the confines of traditional Medicare.

While traditional Medicare covers skilled nursing care for up to 100 days, Medicare Advantage plans often extend this coverage with innovative options.

These plans may offer additional days of skilled nursing care, ensuring a more comprehensive safety net for individuals recovering from illness or surgery.

Under these Medicare Advantage plans, the scope of coverage isn’t solely limited to semi-private rooms, meals, and basic rehabilitative services.

Many plans go the extra mile by incorporating supplementary benefits such as personalized care coordination, in-home recovery services, and access to a broader network of skilled nursing facilities.

This expanded approach aims to provide seniors with a more tailored and holistic recovery experience, aligning with the evolving landscape of healthcare needs.

Moreover, Medicare Advantage plans emphasize preventive care, aiming to reduce the likelihood of hospitalization in the first place.

This proactive approach may include wellness programs, routine check-ups, and early intervention strategies, ultimately contributing to better overall health outcomes for beneficiaries.

In summary, Medicare Advantage plans redefine the post-hospitalization experience by extending and enhancing skilled nursing care beyond the traditional Medicare limits.

With a focus on personalized and preventive care, these plans strive to offer seniors a more comprehensive and adaptable solution for their healthcare needs.

Conclusion

Choosing the best Medicare Advantage Plans for 2024 requires careful consideration of your healthcare needs, budget, and personal preferences.

By understanding the basics of Medicare Advantage Plans, evaluating the advantages and disadvantages, and comparing different plans and insurers, you can make an informed decision that suits your specific needs.

Remember to assess your healthcare needs, review the plan’s network and prescription drug coverage, consider additional benefits, compare costs, and check star ratings.

Take advantage of resources such as insurance brokers and online tools to help you navigate the options available.

With the right information and careful consideration, you can choose the best Medicare Advantage Plan that provides comprehensive coverage, access to quality care, and additional benefits that enhance your healthcare experience.

• Thyroid cancer
• COPD
• Comfort care
• Diabetic meal plans
• Therapy dogs for emotional support
• Respite care
• Top quality urgent care in your area

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)